Creepypasta
by @SilverSpider·59 plays
You know them, you love them, creepypasta
Rank 37 items head-to-head — pick a favorite, one matchup at a time.
Community ranking
Recent rankings (0)
Items to rank (37)
Slenderman
Jeff the Killer
Ben Drowned
Sonic.EXE
MARIO
Laughing Jack
Eyeless Jack
Tails Doll
Suicide Squidward
Photo Negative Mickey
Clockwork
Ticci Toby
Smile Dog
The Rake
Masky
Candle Cove
Cupcakes Pinkie
Mr Widemouth
Suicide Mouse
Herobrine
Rainbow Factory
Jane the Killer
Homicidal Liu
Every Copy is Personalized
