BFDIE Grand Cake
Neckties
Speaker Box chunks
Glass of water
Slice of strawberry topped cheesecake
Flan
Pieces of Ruler costume
Chocolate lava cake
Grassy's feast
Celebratory video clip
Bottle's drawings
Four and X's cake
Planty's vomit
Screech from Evil Leafy
Guitar
Vrrrpt
BFDI DDS
Cheese
Skateboard
A picture for each safe contestant
Items from the storm
A master key to the hotel
Bell's string
Pieces of the moon
Planks and nails
Glue
Yoyle pit
Folders of an attack plan to sneak past Four and X
Ramen noodles
Burrito
Cheesecake with glass shards
Mangosteen
BFB Grand Cake
Silver medal
Gold medal
Bugs
Carrot cake
Lava or water
Have Cots
Piece of Donut's diary
Pieces of Flower's pot
Air to breathe
Salt lamp
Duct tape
Speck of dust
Happy thought
Soup
Burger
Photo cake
Pin's embroidered strawberry cake
Pieces of Firey Speaker Box
Popper topped with a grain of sugar
Tangerine juice
Fortune cookie
Barf cake
An Earth
BFDIA grand cake
Evil forest cake
A recommended character
Durian-infused ambrosia
Mint cupcake
Bubble tea
Steak
Birthday Cake
A grain of rice
Teardrop cake
Poisoned instruments
Pineapple leaves, a basket with a propeller and star stickers
Cake with Jack's hair
Gasoline
Plane ticket
Asbestos cake
Yoyleberries
Donut's corpse
BFDI Grand Cake
Cashew
Red velvet cake
Cheese Orb
Yoylecake
Pizza cake
Shovels caked with mud
Yellow tomato
Cracker
Knives
Explosive blueberry pie
Nickels
Fruitcake
Fish flavored cake
Imaginary cake
Modeling clay
Cupcakes
Ice cream cake
Ice chunk
Key lime pie
Regular cake